What the main Bitcoin cycle models measure
The following definitions explain the inputs, not a ranking of forecasting accuracy. Use one named price feed and daily cutoff for comparisons. An intraday 200-bar average is not a 200-day average, and a chart with too little history cannot supply a complete long lookback.
| Model | Calculation or construction | What the reading does not establish |
|---|
| Pi Cycle Top | 111-day moving average crosses above twice the value of the 350-day moving average | Twice the average value is not a 700-day average; a cross is not proof of a final high. |
| Mayer Multiple | Bitcoin price divided by its 200-day moving average | A multiple measures distance from a baseline, not the probability of a decline. |
| 2-Year MA Multiplier | Compare price with the two-year moving average and five times that average | A historical band is not a guaranteed future ceiling. Verify the provider’s day-count convention. |
| MVRV Z-Score | (market cap − realized cap) / standard deviation of market cap | The denominator’s history and provider implementation matter; this is not a normal-distribution confidence level. |
| NUPL | (market cap − realized cap) / market cap | A value of 0.75 is not evidence that 75% of holders, or nearly all holders, have a profit. |
| RHODL Ratio | Realized-value HODL band of one week divided by the one-to-two-year band, adjusted by market age in days | Coin age is not the age or identity of an investor; transfers need not represent a sale. |
Historical fit is different from a forecast made at the time
Look Into Bitcoin dates Philip Swift’s Pi Cycle Top to April 2019. Its presentation of earlier cycle highs is therefore retrospective evidence, not a record of forecasts issued before those highs. The provider describes historical timing accuracy, but this page has not independently reproduced a complete signal history or measured future performance.
- Specify a peak definition before testing: for example, the highest daily close within a stated future window. That label is only known later and must never be used to decide the earlier trade.
- Record every eligible crossing, including repeated signals, early warnings, missed highs and periods without a signal. Selected successful charts are not a denominator.
- Keep the formula, thresholds and data version fixed for a later evaluation period. Retuning thresholds after each cycle changes the model being evaluated.
- ETF flows, exchange activity and derivatives can change market conditions, but they do not prove that future peak multiples must decline. Market capitalization is price times supply, not the cash required to move the price.
How to audit a 30-indicator dashboard
CoinGlass publishes a Bull Market Peak Indicators checklist with current values, reference levels, hit status and progress fields. A dashboard’s live count, refresh cadence and inputs should be read from its loaded interface; a failed or empty response must not be treated as zero risk. This page does not reproduce its feed or certify that a fixed 30-row set is available.
- For each row, save the provider, formula, timestamp, threshold and whether a higher or lower value triggers the rule. “Progress” needs a defined calculation and is not automatically a probability.
- Several indicators may reuse Bitcoin price or realized capitalization. Treat their dependence explicitly; thirty labels do not supply thirty independent observations.
- Distinguish unavailable from not triggered. As invented arithmetic, 8 hits among 20 available rows is 40% of observed rows; it says nothing about 10 missing rows or a 40% chance of a market top.
- Check the actual data access terms. Viewing a chart does not establish permission to export its history, redistribute it or call a private API from Pine Script.
Use arithmetic to check an exit plan, not to promise a top
Suppose invented market capitalization is $1 trillion and realized capitalization is $400 billion. NUPL is (1,000 − 400) / 1,000 = 0.60. This is an aggregate value ratio under the model. It is not a count of profitable people, an executable liquidation value or a reason by itself to sell.
| Decision | Reproducible specification | Tradeoff to record |
|---|
| Staged reductions | Name the trigger, observation time, fraction and whether the fraction uses original or remaining units | Four sales of 25% of remaining units leave 0.75^4 = 31.640625%; four sales of 25% of the original units exhaust the position. |
| Trailing exit | State the reference price, lookback, distance, ratchet and order type | A stop can fill worse after a gap; a stop-limit may remain unfilled. A wider distance can leave more price risk. |
| Evaluation | Compare the complete plan with a stated baseline after costs and applicable taxes | Early reductions can lower exposure while missing further gains. Neither outcome proves an optimal rule. |
| Destination of proceeds | Name the actual asset and custody arrangement | Cash, Treasury instruments and stablecoins have different liquidity, issuer and redemption risks; they are not interchangeable guarantees. |
What chart analysis and Pine Script can verify
Pineify can help draft price-based cycle calculations or discuss a supplied chart image. A screenshot cannot establish the underlying dataset, unseen history or the accuracy of a provider’s on-chain calculations. A generated script needs syntax and chart checks before use; this page includes no tested strategy or live cycle forecast.
- For a daily price model, specify symbol, exchange, timezone, source and completed-day timing. Check a few values manually against the same input series.
- MVRV, NUPL and RHODL cannot be reconstructed from ordinary OHLC candles alone. TradingView must expose the required series through supported data requests; Pine cannot simply fetch an arbitrary web API.
- A price-only substitute must have its own label. Calling it an on-chain proxy does not establish that it measures realized capitalization or coin-age bands.
- Creating an indicator condition does not create a running TradingView alert. Configure the alert separately and verify the saved script settings and bar timing.