Indexedyennanliu/InvestSkill

Competitor Analysis (InvestSkill)Finance Skill

A single-file research framework for moat hypotheses, Five Forces and competitive benchmarking. Its concentration bands need dated context, and its custom moat score is not a Morningstar rating or a validated valuation rule. Commercial-source access and downstream report tools are not bundled. Treat operating ratios as evidence to investigate, with consistent markets and periods; no analysis output or host compatibility was tested.

Assessment score: 71/100
Snapshot risk: Medium
Audit conclusion: Needs review

How the assessment score works

Pineify weights evidence recorded from the captured files: Skill structure 15%, Instruction clarity 20%, Dependency transparency 20%, Permission transparency 20%, Safety guardrails 15%, Finance task fit 10%. Each signal receives full credit for Yes, one-quarter credit for unknown, and none for No.

The score is not an output accuracy test or user rating. Read the findings and financial assumptions even when the score is high. Risk labels summarize recorded permissions and findings; they do not measure investment risk or certify that installation is safe.

Discovery

What this Skill helps an agent do.

Use the tasks and topics below to judge whether the captured workflow fits your question. Read its findings, dependencies and data requirements before relying on an output.

Finance tasks

Competitive analysis

Domains and assets

Equity researchFundamental analysisPublic equities

Topics

competitor-analysismoatporter-five-forcesmarket-sharecompetitive-benchmarkingpricing-powerinnovationdisruptionindustry-attractivenesscompetitive-intelligence

Trust

Evidence from the captured directory.

This content snapshot assessment does not certify the repository, current files, or installation environment. "Not verified" means the captured files did not support a Yes or No conclusion.

License

MITYes

GitHub reports the repository license as MIT License.

Review state

Automated review: Automated review
Install tested: No
Human reviewed: Not verified

Snapshot

Files reviewed: 1
Captured: 2026-07-29 07:31 UTC
Snapshot ID: fsh-competitor-analysis-yennanliu-2026-07-29-001

Permissions

FilesystemRead

The skill does not read local files. It accepts ticker symbols as input.

FilesystemWrite

The skill does not write local files. Output is presented as text.

NetworkAccess

Yes

Data verification requires web search for current price/market cap. Competitive intelligence sources include SEC EDGAR, Glassdoor, LinkedIn, Gartner, Google Patents, etc. accessed via web search.

ShellExecution

Pure prompt skill with no code execution.

CodeExecution

Pure prompt skill with no code execution.

ExternalCredentials

Not verified

Public filings are named alongside commercial research and account-gated sources; the snapshot does not establish access, subscriptions or credentials for each source.

Dependencies

No dependencies were named in this captured record.

Data sources named by the Skill

Web market data

Web search for current prices, market data, and competitive intelligence sources. No API key required.

SEC EDGAR filings

SEC 10-K and DEF 14A filings for competitive dynamics disclosure. No API key required.

Snapshot assessment

71/100

Pineify Finance Skill snapshot assessment, version 1.0.0. Generated 2026-10-20 00:00 UTC.

Medium risk · Needs review

Skill structure

70/100

Instruction clarity

100/100

Dependency transparency

59/100

Permission transparency

75/100

Safety guardrails

36/100

Finance task fit

80/100

Audit findings

Medium

Separate operating evidence from causal conclusions

Higher gross margin can reflect product mix, input costs or accounting, not just pricing power. Revenue per employee is affected by outsourcing, and patent counts do not measure patent value. Use consistent fiscal periods, currencies, ROIC definitions and peer segments; disclose missing retention and survey data. A 0.5 percentage-point share gain is not a 0.5% relative increase, and its significance depends on the defined market.

Medium

Concentration bands require a dated framework and market definition

The source uses the older 1,500/2,500 HHI bands as universal categories. Current published US 2023 Merger Guidelines describe HHI above 1,800 as highly concentrated and use an increase above 100 in a structural merger presumption. That is a context-specific, rebuttable assessment, not a universal investment or monopoly test. Define product, geography, period and share measure; square percentage-point shares and include the full relevant market.

Medium

The custom score is not a Morningstar rating or valuation rule

Morningstar describes wide, narrow and no-moat ratings; the source adds its own at-risk category, weighted score and cutoffs. Do not attribute that score to Morningstar or infer a required valuation premium from it. A moat affects expected competitive economics, while price paid, cash-flow assumptions, capital needs and risk still determine valuation. Qualitative moat strength alone does not set WACC or terminal growth.

Medium

Resolve score scales and unavailable sources

The Five Forces scale starts at 1, but later becomes 0–5 and is multiplied by two. Choose and disclose a consistent mapping before combining scores; otherwise the component cannot reach zero as claimed. The source provides no performance calibration. Paid research names and downstream slash commands are references, not bundled access or automatic integrations; unavailable figures should remain missing rather than be recalled from training data.

Low

No supporting files or README in the snapshot

The skill directory contains only SKILL.md with no README, reference files, or supporting documentation. All instructions are inline in the 25,454 byte SKILL.md.

Sources and relations

Context around this Skill.

Repository

yennanliu/InvestSkill

topic

Competitive analysis

agent

Claude Code

collection

Financial analysis

guide

Reviewing finance skills before install

Registry

Read this record as data.

The public record includes the page-safe snapshot, evidence, assessment, taxonomy, and relations. Internal revision fields stay outside the public projection.

Record ID: github:yennanliu/investskill:plugins/us-stock-analysis/skills/competitor-analysis
Snapshot ID: fsh-competitor-analysis-yennanliu-2026-07-29-001

Registry JSON

Registry NDJSON

Search Index JSON

This page is an informational registry entry, not investment advice or a security guarantee. A high content quality score does not make the Skill safe for every environment. Review current files, permissions, data sources, and financial assumptions before use.