Who Is the Best Stock Trader in Congress? Comparing Top Portfolios by Returns and Disclosure Records
Determining who is the best stock trader in Congress requires analyzing disclosed portfolio returns from STOCK Act filings, with Nancy Pelosi posting 73% in 2023 as the highest single-year figure, though the ranking carries significant caveats around data completeness and filing timeliness.
The question of who is the best stock trader in Congress does not have a single clean answer — it depends on whether you measure by disclosed portfolio returns, filing consistency, or trade volume. The STOCK Act (Stop Trading on Congressional Knowledge Act) is the 2012 law requiring members of Congress to report securities transactions over $1,000 within 45 days, and it creates the public data we use to evaluate performance. Nancy Pelosi's disclosed trades returned roughly 73% in 2023, based on Unusual Whales analysis — the highest single-year figure I have observed across any congressional portfolio since I began parsing STOCK Act data in early 2023. In 2024, that return dropped to about 38%, still above the S&P 500 but no longer an outlier. Other members like Tommy Tuberville ($38 million in disclosed volume since January 2021) and Josh Gottheimer (consistent filer with a lower late-filing rate) have competing claims depending on the measurement method. The honest answer: there is no consensus best congressional stock trader — the data is incomplete, delayed by up to 45 days, and restricted to the roughly 30-40 most active filers out of 535 members.
How to Get Started
Identify active filers with sufficient trade volume
Most members file fewer than 10 trades per year. Focus on the 30-40 most active filers who have enough transaction history to evaluate. Pineify Market Insights lets you filter by party, chamber, and trade frequency.
Cross-check filing dates against the 45-day STOCK Act window
For each disclosed trade, compare the transaction date to the filing date. Any gap over 45 days means the trade was reported late. Late trades distort performance calculations because the data was not available at the time of the actual transaction.
Estimate returns from dollar ranges and historical prices
Use the reported dollar range midpoint as an estimated transaction value, then compare it to the current or sold-at price for each ticker. The same filing can produce different return estimates depending on the estimation method used.
Evaluate across multiple years, not a single snapshot
A single year of outperformance (like Pelosi's 73% in 2023) may reflect market conditions more than skill. Compare returns across two or more years, and look at the consistency of the filing pattern, not just the percentage returns.
How Congressional Trading Performance Is Measured
Top Congressional Traders by Disclosed Returns
Why Late Filings Distort Performance Rankings
Honest Limitations of Congressional Trading Data
Market Insights Coverage
3,000+
Congressional Filings Parsed
30–40 of 535
Active Filers Tracked for Performance
Since Early 2023
Years Tracking STOCK Act Data
~30% of Filings
Late-Filing Flag Rate (2023-2024)
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions